5 Signs Your Harris County Property is Overvalued for Tax Purposes

Property valuation notices are landing in mailboxes across Harris County, and many homeowners are in shock. With the home valuations in Harris County fluctuating, according to preliminary HCAD data, thousands of properties may be overvalued for tax purposes.

But how do you know if your property is one of them? This guide outlines the five clearest indicators that your Harris County property valuation deserves a closer look—and potentially a protest.

What Constitutes an "Overvalued" Property?

Before diving into the signs, it's important to understand what "overvalued" means in the context of property taxes. In Texas, your property can be considered overvalued in two ways:

  1. Market Value: Your appraised value exceeds what your property would likely sell for on the open market as of January 1st.
  2. Equity: Your property is valued disproportionately higher than similar properties in your area (known as "equal and uniform" taxation).

Both approaches are valid grounds for protest under Texas law, and recognizing the signs of either can save you thousands in property taxes.

Sign #1: Your Valuation Increased Dramatically Despite No Improvements

One of the most obvious red flags is a significant jump in your property's appraised value without corresponding improvements to your home.

What to Look For:

  • Increases over 10% when you haven't renovated, expanded, or significantly improved your property
  • Jumps that far exceed the average increase in your neighborhood
  • Consecutive years of double-digit percentage increases

Sign #2: Your Home Has Condition Issues Not Reflected in the Valuation

The Harris Central Appraisal District typically assesses properties based on exterior observations and statistical models. They don't see what's happening inside your home or underlying issues that affect value.

What to Look For:

  • Foundation problems (common in many Houston neighborhoods)
  • Roof damage or aging roof (especially important after recent storms)
  • Faulty/non-functioning systems (HVAC, electrical, plumbing)
  • Unrepaired water damage (particularly relevant in post-Harvey Houston)
  • Significant deferred maintenance items

Sign #3: Comparable Properties in Your Neighborhood Are Valued Lower

Texas tax law provides for "equal and uniform" taxation, meaning similar properties should be valued similarly. If your property is valued significantly higher than comparable homes, you have strong grounds for protest.

What to Look For:

  • Similar homes (in size, age, and features) with lower valuations
  • Properties on your street with substantially different per-square-foot valuations
  • Homes that have sold recently for less than your appraised value

Sign #4: Recent Sales Data Doesn't Support Your Valuation

The ultimate test of market value is what buyers are actually paying for similar properties. If recent sales don't support your property's valuation, you have a strong case.

What to Look For:

  • Recent sales prices of similar homes in your area
  • Current listings that have been on the market for extended periods at prices below your valuation
  • Downward price trends in your specific neighborhood

Sign #5: There Are Factual Errors in Your Property Record

HCAD maintains records on over 1.8 million properties. With that volume, errors in property descriptions are surprisingly common—and they can significantly impact your valuation.

What to Look For:

  • Incorrect square footage
  • Wrong number of bedrooms or bathrooms
  • Inaccurate lot size
  • Features you don't have (like a pool, garage apartment, or an outdoor kitchen)
  • Incorrect property classification

How to Check if Your Harris County Property is Overvalued

If you recognize any of these signs, your property may indeed be overvalued for tax purposes. Here's how to find out for sure:

  1. Review your property details on the HCAD website for factual accuracy
  2. Research comparable properties in your neighborhood using HCAD's property search
  3. Look up recent sales data through real estate websites or a realtor in your neighborhood & section
  4. Document condition issues with photos and repair estimates

How Outfox Can Help

Identifying that your property is overvalued is one thing—successfully proving it to HCAD is another. This is where Outfox makes the difference:

  • Accurate property valuations in seconds: Our algorithm identifies the most relevant comparable properties HCAD will actually consider
  • Appraiser-friendly protest packet: We organize your evidence, including an executive summary highlighting key points
  • Flat $89.99 fee: Unlike tax agents who take up to 50% of your savings, you pay one affordable price and keep 100% of your tax reductions
  • Deadline reminders: We'll ensure you never miss a critical date in the protest process

Next Steps If Your Property Is Overvalued

If you've identified signs that your Harris County property may be overvalued, don't delay:

  1. File your protest before the May 15th deadline
  2. Generate your professional protest packet for just $89.99
  3. Present your evidence at your hearing
  4. Enjoy the tax savings year after year

Remember: In Harris County, approximately 60-70% of protests result in some reduction. With the right evidence, presented the right way, you stand an excellent chance of success.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice.