Preparing Your Evidence for Property Tax Hearings

Effective Hearing Evidence: Just the facts

When preparing for a property tax protest hearing, the quality of your evidence can significantly impact the outcome. Strong evidence typically includes:

  • Relevant ADJUSTED Sales Comparables: Properties similar to yours that have recently sold, with appropriate adjustments for differences in features, size, or condition.
  • Condition Issues: Documentation of property defects that affect value, including:
    • Clear, dated/timestamped photographs showing problems
  • Professional Estimates
    • Estimates from qualified and licensed contractors or tradespeople for repairs
    • NOT INVOICES, the District does not consider/reimburse for condition issues that have been restored.

What the District Does Not Value: Valuable, yet unvalued.

It's important to understand that certain property features are not considered in the District's valuation process. These typically include:

  • Driveways
  • Fences
  • Landscaping
  • Water heaters and home appliances
  • Pest Control/Mold Remediation

Focusing your evidence on these elements alone will not strengthen your case.

Evidence Presentation Requirements: Show them what you're working with

For In-Person Hearings

  • Informal Hearings: Bring one complete set of evidence for the appraiser's records
  • Formal Hearings: Bring five (5) copies of all evidence:
    • One set for yourself
    • One set for the District appraiser
    • One set for each ARB member (typically three)

For Remote Hearings

  • Upload all evidence to your iFile account before the hearing date
  • Have digital copies readily accessible on your computer
  • Be prepared to share your screen to present evidence during the hearing

Well-organized, relevant evidence presented in the correct format will give you the best chance of a successful property tax protest.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice.